Poison is the first thing many people reach for when they find rats in the shed. It is cheap, it is sold in most hardware stores, and it asks nothing of you beyond putting a few blocks in a corner. It also sits in the same garden as a curious dog, a roaming cat and the occasional child.
This article is about the risks, not a how-to. The aim is to help you decide whether poison belongs on your section at all, and if you use it, to avoid the common mistakes.
The SPCA's page on whether rat bait is dangerous for pets explains that most rodenticides are anticoagulants. Examples it names include warfarin, brodifacoum, bromadiolone and flocoumafen, which cause bleeding that can lead to death. Other types include cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) and zinc phosphide.
The SPCA is blunt about the reach of these products: rodenticides can affect any mammal or bird in the same way they affect a rodent. That includes dogs, cats, wildlife and people.
The SPCA describes two routes. A pet can eat the bait itself, or it can eat a rat that has eaten the bait, which is called secondary poisoning. Whichever route is involved, bait should never be left where a dog or cat can find it, and it should be in a secured bait station rather than loose on the ground.
DOC's overview of traps and toxins makes a related point about different products. First-generation anticoagulants such as coumatetralyl, diphacinone and pindone stay in the body for a shorter time than second-generation toxins, which lowers the risk of by-kill. DOC reserves second-generation anticoagulants for special cases. It also lists cholecalciferol, which it says has a low secondary poisoning risk and can be used without a licence, but only in bait stations and after one pre-feed of non-toxic bait.
Whatever the product, bait stations are the rule. DOC's descriptions repeatedly say toxins "must be in bait stations".
According to the SPCA, bleeding is often internal, so you may not see any outside the body. Signs include:
Signs can take several days to appear after exposure, so a pet that seems fine on the day it ate bait may still be at risk.
If you suspect poisoning, contact a vet promptly. Take the packet with you or note the product name, because the active ingredient matters for treatment. Do not wait for symptoms to appear.
The SPCA recommends using "other, more humane, methods of rodent control" where at all possible, in order to protect children, pets and wildlife. For many people the main reason to trap is that there is no residue and no bait to find.
Traps have their own risks, but they can be managed. DOC's trap guide says kill traps should be placed in a tunnel or cover, which guides the animal in, helps it die humanely and limits by-kill and access by non-target species. It suggests side-entry or extended-entrance tunnel designs where domestic cats are about. A tunnel on the ground with a small entrance and a closed lid is much harder for a dog to interfere with than an open tray of poison.
Some trap types are described by DOC as safe for children and pets, including the Envirotools D Rat, Lumberjack and Supervisor Max. The page does not give pet-safety claims for the other trap models it lists, so check the manufacturer's instructions for each.
Sometimes a household has no practical alternative. A large infestation, an inaccessible roof void or a heavy rat population can make poison tempting. If that is your situation:
DOC also notes that poison tends to work better at higher pest densities where trapping is labour-intensive, and that switching methods helps avoid trap-shy or poison-shy pests. In other words, there is a place for bait in large-scale conservation work, but a suburban section is a different problem from a forest.
Poison does not respect species boundaries. Anything that eats the bait, or a poisoned animal, may be affected. Predator Free NZ's guidance names native birds such as weka as a reason to keep toxic baits away from certain sites.
If you have pets, young children or a bush-edge section with native birds, start with traps in tunnels. You can see exactly what you have caught, and they do not rely on a delayed, hidden effect. If you have already used bait and now suspect a pet has eaten some, treat it as urgent and call your vet.