It is tempting to treat a mouse as a small rat and reuse the same traps. That works about half the time. Mice are lighter, quicker to multiply and far better at squeezing into places, and those differences change how you set a trap line.
Hawke's Bay Regional Council describes the house mouse as weighing up to 30 grams and measuring about 115 mm without its tail, dull grey-brown above and grey below, with large black eyes and a thin tail. It also describes them as prolific breeders, with a single mouse able to produce up to 60 young in a year. That breeding rate is why a handful of mice can become a household problem quickly, and why an early catch is worth more than a late one. The council's house mouse page also notes that mice tend to live in clutter such as old newspapers, boxes and rags, and behind fridges or in hot water cupboards.
Their size matters in another way. Predator Free NZ's overview points out that lizards can escape rats by hiding in tiny crevices, but mice can squeeze in and find them. Mice also eat a lot of invertebrates. A five-year study at Maungatautari found that high mouse numbers limited invertebrate populations, which then affects the birds that eat caterpillars and wētā. That research is covered in Predator Free NZ's article on whether mice matter.
A rat trap often will not fire for a mouse, because the animal is too light to press the plate. DOC's backyard setup deals with both at once: a tunnel with the rat trap slid in first and a mouse trap behind it, with a teaspoon of peanut butter on each. Place the tunnel against a wall or bank, keep the traps toward the back so pets and children are less likely to be caught, and put a small amount of free peanut butter in front of the trap. The full steps are on DOC's trap predators in your backyard page.
Hawke's Bay Regional Council suggests trapping is best for small infestations in and around buildings. Use covers such as coreflute to keep lures dry and stop other animals being caught, and re-lure traps regularly.
Peanut butter is the default for mice, and the council notes it works well. A trial on Quail Island, covered by Predator Free NZ, offers a more detailed picture. Where mouse numbers were high, peanut butter in Victor snap traps caught 15.2 per cent of mice, compared with 7.1 per cent for corn in the same traps. Where numbers were lower, corn and peanut butter did about the same, and combining them lifted the catch to 12.1 per cent. Wētā were filmed removing peanut butter from ground traps, so a combination bait left corn behind when the peanut butter was gone. That trial was on an island, so treat the percentages as a guide to which bait performs relatively well and not as a promise for your hallway. See Predator Free NZ's Quail Island write-up for the detail.
Inside a house, where wētā are not an issue, peanut butter works fine. Outdoors, a nut-and-grain combination is worth trying if the bait keeps vanishing without a catch.
Mice follow walls and edges as rats do, so run traps along them. Check likely hiding places:
Because a mouse can find a gap that a rat cannot, the real fix is sealing. Hawke's Bay Regional Council's prevention advice is to clean up clutter inside and outside, seal building entrances, keep areas around buildings clear and rodent-proof the compost. Cats and dogs usually will not solve a mouse problem on their own.
Most rodent poisons are anticoagulants, and the council notes that mice generally die within seven days of a lethal dose. It also warns that rodenticides are very harmful to dogs and cats, and that baits should be kept away from children, pets and stock. If you suspect a child has eaten bait, contact the National Poisons Centre or emergency services straight away. A vet should be contacted at once if a dog or cat may have eaten bait. Traps are safer around a family home when they are in a tunnel or covered box. For a worked overview of mouse control inside houses, including how to find where they are getting in, that is a useful next read.
Public health researchers say rodent urine should be treated as potentially infectious, so wear gloves when emptying traps and cleaning up, and wash your hands afterwards. Keep food covered and in sealed containers while you have a problem.
If you have a fast-growing infestation inside the house, mouse numbers can outrun a few traps. A specialist such as Pest Control West Auckland can find the entry points and put in a more systematic plan, and professional help is worth considering if catches keep coming after a month.