Ask ten trappers what they put in a rat trap and you will get ten answers, usually delivered with some conviction. Peanut butter has been the default for decades, but a small body of research and plenty of field experience suggest it is not the only option, and it may not be the best one.
This guide sorts out what is actually known, what is anecdote, and how to apply both on your own line.
DOC's guidance on choosing traps and toxins lists lures for rats as peanut butter (including a version mixed with rolled oats), other nut or chocolate lures, and commercial products such as the Goodnature Rat Lure and Traps.co.nz rat lures. For stoats and weasels the list shifts to fresh rabbit meat and egg-based lures, and for possums to peanut butter, dough and commercial blends.
Peanut butter is cheap, easy to find and easy to smear in a trap. That is why it became the default, and why it works well enough that many people never change it.
Researchers at Victoria University of Wellington tested a range of food products on wild, free-ranging rats using chew cards. Predator Free NZ's summary of the research on better baits says the rats preferred cheese, milk chocolate, Nutella and walnut over peanut butter, the standard lure. Their intake was driven mainly by energy, especially fats, so adding fat to a rat bait may increase consumption. The work was published in the Journal of Pest Science in 2016.
Two caveats are worth keeping in mind. The test measured how attractive foods were and how much was eaten on chew cards, not how many rats a trap caught over a season. And the study did not report findings on mice.
Predator Free NZ's article on fresh lure ideas gathers some practical options:
A pair of New Zealand trappers quoted in that article moved from peanut butter to a varied "predator buffet" kit of jam, cinnamon, apple, oats, salmon oil and other items. They report their catch rate has increased, although no figures are given. That is anecdote rather than evidence, but it points to the same idea as the research: variety and fat tend to help.
The article's own summary is that no single lure is best, because effectiveness depends on the time of year, the weather and what food is available. In a season when natural food is plentiful, a rat has less reason to investigate your trap. When food is scarce, almost anything may work.
That is a good reason to keep a record. If you log the lure with each catch, you will find out what works on your section instead of guessing. Predator Free NZ's guidance on trap results lists bait used as one of the things worth recording.
Predator Free NZ's advanced trapping tips suggest placing bait high in the trap so the scent drifts out, and leaving small treats such as mutton fat crumbs or peanut butter near the entrance. The article on lures describes the one-third rule from trapper Cam Speedy: one third of the bait inside the trap, one third at the entrance and one third spread around the area.
Use less than you think you need. Keep the amount modest and tuck it where the animal has to commit to the trap to reach it.
Where native birds live nearby, think about who else might want the lure. The Predator Free NZ write-up notes that kākā and kea like apricots and almonds, which is why cinnamon is described as the safer option for possum baits in places they live. Always put traps in a tunnel or cover. DOC's guide says this guides the animal in, helps it die humanely and limits access by non-target species.
If a trap is catching nothing, change one thing at a time. Swap the lure, then move the trap if that does not help. Use the same lure at two stations for a month and compare. Mark each change in your notebook. A season of notes will tell you more than a dozen opinions.